The Inspection Panel was established by identical Resolutions of the Boards of Executive Directors of IBRD and IDA in 1993. In response to complaints from project-affected communities, IPN is an independent, “bottom-up” accountability and recourse mechanism that investigates IBRD/IDA financed projects to determine whether the Bank has complied with its operational policies and procedures (including social and environmental safeguards), and to address related issues of harm. Find out more at: www.inspectionpanel.org
Mission, Roles, Responsibility and Areas of Focus
Mission: Serve as independent forum to provide accountability and recourse for communities affected by IBRD/IDA-financed projects, to address harms resulting from policy non-compliance, and to help improve development effectiveness of WBG operations. Promote more inclusive and sustainable development by giving project-affected people, including those who are often poor and most vulnerable, greater voice in Bank-financed projects that affect them.
-
Roles, Responsibility and Areas of Focus (for details see “The Inspection Panel at 15 Years”, 2009):
- Independent fact-finding, accountability and recourse: In response to complaints from project-affected communities, independently investigates whether Bank Management has complied with its operational policies and procedures in projects financed by IBRD/IDA, and whether harm has resulted from non-compliance.
- Problem-solving for affected people: In addition to its well known role in assessing compliance, the Panel process plays a critical role in helping to resolve problems facing project-affected people. Problemsolving occurs at various stages: pre-registration (affected people must approach Management first); eligibility; investigation; and follow-up. The process places responsibility and creates opportunities for Management to take effective responsive actions to address problems. The Panel is considering additional options to enhance opportunities for problem solving under its process.
- Check and balance for Board: Provides an independent, technically based check and balance for Board on situation(s) relating to compliance and harm in project operations.
- Transparency and participation: Promotes transparency in Bank operations through publication of reports and findings, and by serving as independent venue for affected people to raise concerns to highest decision-making levels of Bank.
-
Key outputs and practices:
- Eligibility reports: Assesses eligibility of Requests for Inspection through Eligibility Reports, which contain a recommendation on whether to investigate the matters alleged in Request. The “eligibility” stage also yields an initial Management Response to the Request, and important opportunities for early problem-solving.
- Investigation reports and findings: Independent investigation and fact-finding assesses project-level policy compliance, and leads to remedies for harm to people and environment. Findings reported directly to the Board.
- Bank Management Responses and Action Plan: In response to Panel findings on compliance and harm, Bank Management prepares Response and Action Plan (with Government) to address findings. Reports and findings are made available to requesters, affected people and the public
- Systemic Observations, Corporate Learning: Investigation Reports and Management Responses include systemic observations and lessons learned which promote corporate learning and transparency through their publication.
- Public Awareness: Produces publications to inform public of its activities and for outreach (Annual Report, press releases, etc).
- Institution-wide incentives/impacts: Creates ongoing incentives for institution to comply with policies and procedures, including social and environmental safeguards; supports overall Bank mission to fight poverty and helps Bank avoid actions causing reputational risk.
-
The Inspection Panel engages with the following internal and external stakeholders: - Board (reports directly to the Board);
- Management (independent, investigates compliance, interactive approach to problemsolving, fact-finding and lessons-learned);
- External Stakeholders (the Inspection Panel gives voice to project affected people and builds awareness through outreach).
| Case No. | Country | Year | Project |
|---|---|---|---|
| 119 | India | 2017 | Amaravati Sustainable Capital City Development Project(P159808) |
| 118 | Vietnam | 2017 | Livestock Competitiveness and Food Safety(P090723) and Additional Financing to Livestock Competitiveness and Food Safety Project(P151946) |
| 117 | Serbia | 2017 | Floods Emergency Recovery Project (P152018) |
| 116 | Bangladesh | 2016 | Bangladesh Modern Food Storage Facilities Project(P120583) |
| 115 | Kenya | 2016 | Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project(P096367) and Water and Sanitation Service Improvement Project - Additional Financing(P126637) |
| 114 | India | 2016 | Proposed Amaravati Sustainable Capital City Development Project |
| 113 | Uganda | 2016 | Private Power Generation (Bujagali), Water Management and Development, and Energy for Rural Transformation III Projects (Second Request) |
| 112 | India | 2016 | Andhra Pradesh & Telengana Road Sector and National Highways Interconnectivity Improvement Project |
| 111 | Bangladesh | 2016 | Trade and Transport Studies RETF Project |
| 110 | Uganda | 2016 | Private Power Generation (Bujagali), Water Management and Development, and Energy for Rural Transformation III Projects |
| 109 | Mexico | 2016 | Urban Transport Transformation Project |
| 108 | Colombia | 2016 | Rio Bogota Environmental Recuperation and Flood Control Project (P111479) |
| 107 | Armenia | 2016 | Irrigation System Enhancement Project (Second Request) |
| 106 | Armenia | 2016 | Irrigation System Enhancement Project (First Request) |
| 105 | India | 2015 | Andhra Pradesh & Telangana Road Sector Project and National Highways Interconnectivity Improvement Project |
| 104 | Serbia | 2015 | Floods Emergency Recovery Project (P152018) |
| 103 | Kosovo | 2015 | Proposed Kosovo Power Project and Second Additional Financing Energy Sector Clean-up and Land Reclamation Project |
| 102 | Mongolia | 2015 | Mongolia Mining Infrastructure Investment Support (P118109) and Mining Infrastructure Investment Support - Additional Financing (P145439) |
| 101 | Togo | 2015 | Integrated Disaster and Land Management |
| 100 | Haiti | 2015 | Haiti Mining Dialogue Technical Assistance |
| 99 | India | 2014 | Second Tamil Nadu Road Sector Project (Proposed) |
| 98 | Uganda | 2014 | Transport Sector Development Project - Additional Financing |
| 97 | Kenya | 2014 | Electricity Expansion Project |
| 96 | Kazakhstan | 2014 | South-West Roads: Western Europe-Western China International Transit Corridor - CAREC-1b & 6b (2010) (Third Request) (Not Registered) |
| 95 | Paraguay | 2014 | Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development Project (Pilot - Not Registered) |
| 94 | Armenia | 2014 | Second Education Quality and Relevance Project, Education Improvement Project |
| 93 | Tajikistan/Kyrgyz Republic/Afghanistan/Pakistan | 2014 | Central Asia South Asia Electricity Transmission and Trade Project (CASA-1000) (Not Registered) |
| 92 | Sri Lanka | 2014 | Road Sector Assistance Project - Second Additional Financing (Not Registered) |
| 91 | Nigeria | 2013 | Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project (Pilot - Not Registered) |
| 90 | Nepal | 2013 | Enhanced Vocational Education and Training Project (Not Registered) |
| 89 | Uzbekistan | 2013 | Second Rural Enterprise Support Project |
| 88 | Romania | 2013 | Mine Closure, Environment and Socio-Economic Regeneration Project (Not Registered) |
| 87 | Nepal | 2013 | Power Development Project |
| 86 | Malawi | 2013 | Second National Water Development Project - Additional Financing (Not Registered) |
| 85 | Egypt, Arab Republic of | 2013 | Giza North Power Project |
| 84 | Kenya | 2013 | Natural Resource Management Project |
| 83 | Afghanistan | 2012 | Sustainable Development of Natural Resources – Additional Financing, and Sustainable Development of Natural Resources II |
| 82 | Ethiopia | 2012 | Protection of Basic Services Program Phase II Additional Financing and Promoting Basic Services Phase III Project |
| 81 | India | 2012 | Vishnugad Pipalkoti Hydro Electric Project |
| 80 | India | 2012 | Improving Rural Livelihoods through Carbon Sequestration Project |
| 79 | Kenya | 2012 | Energy Sector Recovery Project |
| 78 | Kosovo | 2012 | Kosovo Power Project (Proposed) |
| 77 | Argentina | 2011 | Santa Fe Infrastructure Project and Provincial Road Infrastructure Project (Not Registered) |
| 76 | Israel/Jordan/West Bank and Gaza | 2011 | Red Sea - Dead Sea Water Conveyance Study Program |
| 75 | India | 2011 | Madhya Pradesh Water Sector Restructuring Project (2011) (Second Request) |
| 74 | Kazakhstan | 2011 | South-West Roads: Western Europe-Western China International Transit Corridor - CAREC-1b & 6b (2011) (Second Request) |
| 73 | Argentina | 2011 | Second Norte Grande Water Infrastructure Project |
| 72 | India | 2010 | Madhya Pradesh Water Sector Restructuring Project (2010) (First Request) |
| 71 | Lebanon | 2010 | Greater Beirut Water Supply Project |
| 70 | Tajikistan | 2010 | Energy Loss Reduction Project (Request from Uzbekistan) |
| 69 | Liberia | 2010 | Development Forestry Sector Management Project |
| 68 | Poland | 2010 | Third Employment, Entrepreneurship and Human Capital Development Policy Loan (Not Registered) |
| 67 | Chile | 2010 | Quilleco Hydropower Project |
| 66 | Kazakhstan | 2010 | South-West Roads: Western Europe-Western China International Transit Corridor - CAREC-1b & 6b (2010) (First Request) |
| 65 | South Africa | 2010 | Eskom Investment Support Project |
| 64 | Pakistan | 2009 | Tax Administration Reform Project |
| 63 | Congo, Democratic Republic of | 2009 | Private Sector Development and Competitiveness Project (Third Request) |
| 62 | Papua New Guinea | 2009 | Smallholder Agriculture Development Project |
| 61 | Peru | 2009 | Lima Urban Transport Project |
| 60 | Cambodia | 2009 | Land Management and Administration Project |
| 59 | Kenya | 2009 | Export Development Project (Not Registered) |
| 58 | India | 2009 | Mumbai Urban Transport Project (Third Request) |
| 57 | Yemen, Republic of | 2009 | Institutional Reform Development Policy Financing |
| 56 | Panama | 2009 | Land Administration Project (Second Request) |
| 55 | Congo, Democratic Republic of | 2009 | Private Sector Development and Competitiveness Project (Second Request) |
| 54 | Congo, Democratic Republic of | 2009 | Private Sector Development and Competitiveness Project (First Request) |
| 53 | Panama | 2009 | Land Administration Project (First Request) |
| 52 | Colombia | 2007 | Bogota Urban Services Project |
| 51 | Argentina | 2007 | Santa Fe Road Infrastructure Project and Provincial Road Infrastructure Project (Third Request) |
| 50 | Cameroon | 2007 | Urban Development Project and Douala Infrastructure Development Project (Not Registered) |
| 49 | Ghana | 2007 | Second Urban Environment Sanitation Project |
| 48 | Albania | 2007 | Integrated Coastal Zone Management and Clean-Up Project (Second Request) |
| 47 | Albania | 2007 | Integrated Coastal Zone Management and Clean-Up Project (First Request) |
| 46 | Albania | 2007 | Power Sector Generation and Restructuring Project |
| 45 | India | 2007 | Uttaranchal Decentralized Watershed Development Project |
| 44 | Uganda | 2007 | Private Power Generation Project |
| 43 | Argentina | 2006 | Santa Fe Infrastructure Project (Proposed) and Provincial Road Infrastructure Project (Second Request) |
| 42 | Argentina | 2006 | Santa Fe Infrastructure Project (Proposed) and Provincial Road Infrastructure Project (First Request) |
| 41 | Brazil | 2006 | Parana Biodiversity Project |
| 40 | Ghana/Nigeria | 2006 | West African Gas Pipeline Project |
| 39 | Romania | 2006 | Mine Closure and Social Mitigation Project |
| 38 | Honduras | 2006 | Land Administration Project |
| 37 | Congo, Democratic Republic of | 2005 | Transitional Support for Economic Recovery Credit and Emergency Economic and Social Reunification Support Project |
| 36 | Cambodia | 2005 | Forest Concession Management and Control Pilot Project |
| 35 | Burundi | 2004 | Public Works and Employment Creation Project (Not Registered) |
| 34 | Pakistan | 2004 | National Drainage Program Project |
| 33 | India | 2004 | Mumbai Urban Transport Project (Second Request) |
| 32 | India | 2004 | Mumbai Urban Transport Project (First Request) |
| 31 | Colombia | 2004 | Cartagena Water Supply, Sewerage and Environmental Project |
| 30 | Mexico | 2004 | Indigenous and Community Biodiversity Project (COINBIO) |
| 29 | Cameroon | 2003 | Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project (Not Registered) |
| 28 | Philippines | 2003 | Manila Second Sewerage Project (MSSP) |
| 27 | Cameroon | 2002 | Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project, and Petroleum Environment Capacity Enhancement Project |
| 26 | Paraguay/Argentina | 2002 | Paraguay/Argentina Reform Project for the Water and Telecommunications Sectors, SEGBA V Power Distribution Project (Yacyretá) |
| 25 | Papua New Guinea | 2001 | Governance Promotion Adjustment Loan |
| 24 | Uganda | 2001 | Third Power Project, Fourth Power Project, and Proposed Bujugali Hydropower Project |
| 23 | India | 2001 | Coal Sector Mitigation Project and Coal Sector Rehabilitation Project |
| 22 | Chad | 2001 | Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project, Management of the Petroleum Economy Project, and Petroleum Sector Management Capacity Building Project |
| 21 | India | 1999 | NTPC Power Generation Project (Second Request) |
| 20 | Ecuador | 1999 | Mining Development and Environmental Control Assistance Project |
| 19 | Kenya | 1999 | Lake Victoria Environmental Management Project |
| 18 | Brazil | 1999 | Land Reform and Poverty Alleviation Pilot Project (Second Request) |
| 17 | Argentina | 1999 | Special Structural Adjustment Loan |
| 16 | China | 1999 | Western Poverty Reduction Project |
| 15 | Lesotho | 1999 | Highlands Water Project - Phase 1B (Second Request - from Lesotho and South Africa) |
| 14 | Brazil | 1998 | Land Reform and Poverty Alleviation Pilot Project (First Request) |
| 13 | Nigeria | 1998 | Lagos Drainage and Sanitation Project |
| 12 | Lesotho | 1998 | Proposed Phase 1B of Lesotho Highland Water Project (First Request - from South Africa) |
| 11 | India | 1998 | Ecodevelopment Project |
| 10 | India | 1997 | NTPC I Power Generation Project |
| 9 | Brazil | 1997 | Itaparica Resettlement and Irrigation Project |
| 8 | Bangladesh | 1996 | Jamuna New Multipurpose Bridge Project |
| 7 | Argentina/Paraguay | 1996 | Yacyretá Hydroelectric Project |
| 6 | Bangladesh | 1996 | Jute Sector Adjustment Credit |
| 5 | Chile | 1995 | Financing of Hydroelectric Dams in the Bío-Bío River (Not Registered) |
| 4 | Brazil | 1995 | Rondônia Natural Resources Management Project |
| 3 | Tanzania | 1995 | Power VI Project |
| 2 | Ethiopia | 1995 | Compensation for Expropriation and Extension of IDA Credits to Ethiopia (Not Registered) |
| 1 | Nepal | 1994 | Arun III Proposed Hydroelectric Project and Restructuring of IDA Credit |