http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/about/
The Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) is the independent recourse mechanism for the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA). The CAO responds to complaints from project-affected communities with the goal of enhancing social and environmental outcomes on the ground.
http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/about/
CAO's mission is to address complaints by people affected by IFC/MIGA projects and to enhance the social and environmental accountability of both institutions.
http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/about/
The CAO is the independent recourse mechanism for projects supported by IFC and MIGA, the private sector lending arms of the World Bank Group.
Governance
CAO is independent and reports direct to the President of the World Bank Group. CAO's mandate is articulated in its Terms of Reference.
Staff
CAO's diverse team includes professionals from the public and private sectors with expertise in dispute resolution, environmental compliance, research, advocacy, communications, and more.
Partners
CAO partners include the independent recourse mechanisms (IRMs) of other international financial institutions.
Our Roles The CAO works through three unique and complimentary roles: Ombudsman, Compliance auditor, and Advisor.
FundingCAO funds all assessments of complaints, compliance audits, and advisory work from its operating budget.
Strategic Advisors CAO's Strategic Advisors Group is comprised of professionals from civil society, private industry, academia, and the field of mediation and conflict resolution..
http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/about/whoweare/
As the independent recourse mechanism for IFC and MIGA, CAO helps address the concerns of communities who believe they are affected by IFC/MIGA projects with the aim of improving social and environmental outcomes on the ground.
CAO's mandate
The Office of the Compliance Advisor/Ombudsman (CAO) is the independent recourse mechanism for projects supported by the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA)--the private sector lending arms of the World Bank Group. CAO was established in 1999 and reports directly to the President of the World Bank Group.
CAO works to:
- Address the concerns of individuals or communities affected by IFC/MIGA projects
- Enhance the social and environmental outcomes of IFC/MIGA projects; and
- Foster greater public accountability of IFC and MIGA
The Office of the CAO is based in Washington, DC.
CAO Operational Guidelines
CAO's Operational Guidelines explain how CAO carries out its work in response to complaints and requests for audit related to IFC/MIGA supported projects. Specifically, the Operational Guidelines aim to provide a predictable process to guide complainants and other stakeholders through CAO's complaint-handling process. The guidelines are available in the seven official languages of the World Bank Group (see below).
Revised Operational Guidelines 2013
During 2012-13, CAO updated its Operational Guidelines in response to recommendations from recent external reviews of CAO’s effectiveness by the World Bank Group Board and an independent review team. The revised Operational Guidelines were released in March 2013. Click here for more details.
CAO's Terms of Reference
CAO's mandate is articulated in itsTerms of Reference (TOR), which were endorsed by the President of the World Bank Group in 1999.
http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/about/ourroles/
The CAO has three unique and complimentary roles, which together provide a flexible framework for handling people's complaints and addressing systemic concerns about IFC and MIGA projects.
The CAO's Three Roles
Dispute Resolution (formerly Ombudsman)
CAO Ombudsman responds to complaints by people affected by the social and environmental impacts of IFC/MIGA projects. CAO Dispute Resolution works with stakeholders to resolve grievances using a flexible problem-solving approach, and ideally improving outcomes on the ground. CAO specialists are trained in alternative dispute resolution, with expertise in conflict assessment and management, mediation, and facilitation. Learn more about our Dispute Resolution role.
Compliance
CAO Compliance oversees investigations of IFC and MIGA's social and environmental performance, particularly in relation to sensitive projects to ensure compliance with relevant policies, guidelines, procedures, and systems. Learn more about our Compliance role.
Advisor
CAO Advisor provides independent advice to the President of the World Bank Group and management of IFC and MIGA. CAO advice focuses on broader social and environmental concerns, policies, procedures, strategic issues, and trends. CAO's emphasis is on improving IFC/MIGA's performance systemically. Learn more about our Advisory role.
The CAO was created in 1999 to address complaints relating to the World Bank Group’s private sector arms – the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and the Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA). The CAO’s office has Advisory and Compliance functions, but it considers its Ombudsman function as its primary and most important responsibility. The Ombudsman function was designed to respond to complaints by persons who are affected by IFC/MIGA projects by “attempting to resolve fairly the issues raised, using a flexible, problem-solving approach.” Any individual, group, community, entity, or other party affected or likely to be affected by the social or environmental impacts of an IFC or MIGA project may make a complaint to the Ombudsman. Representatives of those affected by a project may also file a complaint with appropriate proof of representation. The CAO acknowledges receipt of all complaints and evaluates whether the complaint falls within its mandate, and, if it does, whether to accept or reject the complaint. A complaint must demonstrate that the affected party has been, or is likely to be, affected by actual or potential social or environmental impacts on the ground. The complaint must relate to an aspect of the planning, implementation, or impact of an IFC or MIGA project.
Once a complaint is accepted, the CAO immediately notifies the complainant, registers the complaint, refers the complaint to the relevant IFC or MIGA personnel with a request for information, and informs the project sponsor of the complaint. The CAO then undertakes an assessment to determine how it proposes to handle the complaint. During the assessment, the CAO will communicate with the claimant, the project sponsor, and the IFC to attempt to identify a process for resolving the dispute. The CAO’s proposal may include anything from convening informal consultations with IFC/MIGA or the project sponsor to organizing a more formal mediation process. Overall, the ombudsman’s office seeks to take a proactive and flexible approach where the “aim is to identify problems, recommend practical remedial action and address systemic issues that have contributed to the problems, rather than to find fault.” If at any time after completion of the assessment the CAO Ombudsman believes that resolution of the complaint is not possible, the complaint is automatically transferred to the compliance side of the CAO for an assessment of whether a Compliance audit is warranted.
In both its Ombudsman and Compliance roles, the CAO has broad investigatory powers, including authority to review IFC or MIGA files; meet with the affected people, IFC or MIGA staff, project sponsors, and host country government officials; conduct project site visits; hold public meetings in the project area; request written submissions from any source; and engage expert consultants to research or address specific issues. Compliance audit findings are sent to senior IFC/MIGA staff for comment and ultimately to the President of the World Bank Group for review. The CAO concludes the complaint process either when an agreement has been reached through the Ombudsman or when the IFC/MIGA are deemed to be in compliance with their policies. In this regard, the CAO will keep any compliance audit “open and monitor the situation” until it is satisfied that IFC/MIGA are moving back into compliance. The Compliance audits and monitoring status of any projects under review are made public.
As of the end of 2010, the CAO’s office had received 79 claims, involving 41 different projects. While some of these claims have resulted in long and complex involvement by the CAO, others have involved relatively short interventions.
http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/newsroom/documents/CAOOutreachPresentation-GhanaVC-December2017.pdf
Independent Accountability Mechanism for IFC & MIGA, World Bank Group Meeting with Civil Society Organizations in Accra, Ghana December 14, 2017
What is CAO?
- Independent accountability mechanism (“grievance mechanism”) for IFC and MIGA – the private sector arms of the World Bank Group
- CAO addresses complaints from communities affected by IFC and MIGA projects
- The goal of CAO’s work is to improve environmental and social project outcomes
Why was CAO Created?
- “50 Years is Enough”: Pressure on World Bank Group in 1990s due to ‘problem projects’ and perceived lack of accountability
- CAO was established in 1999 to provide redress for local communities impacted by IFC and MIGA projects
- Today, all multilateral banks have Independent Accountability Mechanisms (IAMs) Channel for project affected people to raise concerns at highest level of decision-making
Where CAO Interacts
IFC & MIGA: Members of the World Bank Group
Conciliation and arbitration of investment disputes Guarantees of foreign direct investment noncommercial risks Interest-free loans and grants to governments of poorest countries Loans to middle-income and credit-worthy low-income country governments Finance for private sector development IBRD International Bank for Reconstruction and Development IDA International Development Association IFC International Finance Corporation MIGA Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency ICSID International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
- Anticipate risks, avoid, minimize and compensate for any impacts.
2 Treat workers fairly and provide safe and healthy working conditions.
3 Promote energy efficiency, use resources sustainably, and cut greenhouse emissions.
4 Protect local communities from worksite accidents and other project-related dangers.
5 Avoid involuntary resettlement and minimize the impact on those displaced.
6 Protect biodiversity and ecosystems.
7 Protect the rights, dignity, and culture of indigenous populations.
RISK MANAGEMENT LABOR RESOURCE EFFICIENCY COMMUNITY LAND RESETTLEMENT BIODIVERSITY INDIGENOUS PEOPLES CULTURAL HERITAGE Protect cultural heritage and promote equitable sharing of related benefits.
IFC/MIGA Environmental and Social Commitments
- POLICY ON ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL SUSTAINABILITY
- POLICY ON ACCESS TO INFORMATION
www.ifc.org/sustainability
What Complaints Can CAO Accept?
- IFC or MIGA project
- Environmental and social issues
- People who believe they are, or may be, impacted by the project
- Any format and any language
- CSOs often support communities in filing complaints
How CAO Works
- Achieving remedy
- Dialogue
- Clients and communities
- Determining IFC/MIGA compliance
- IFC/MIGA project impacts
- Independent advice
- Improving performance
Who files complaints to CAO?
Profile of Complainants, FY2017 Percentages do not add up to 100% because three complaints were filed by more than one type of organization. The category for individuals and community members denotes complaints filed without the support of another organization.
Complaints by Region, FY2017
51 cases in 28 countries
Complaints by Sector, FY2017
Environmental and
social issues raised by complainants, FY2017
CAO Cases in
Sub-Saharan Africa
Cameroon & Chad: Chad-Cameroon Oil Pipeline Guinea: Nedbank/Siguiri gold mine Kenya: Bidco (Consumer goods manufacturing) South Africa: Lonmin/Marikana mine Togo: Lomé Port Development Uganda: Bujagali Hydropower Project Uganda: Agri-Vie/New Forests Company (commercial forestry)
The complaint process in more detail
- Achieving remedy
- Dialogue
- Clients and communities
- Determining IFC/MIGA compliance
- IFC/MIGA project impacts
- Independent advice
- Improving performance
Complaint Assessment
Objectives:
- Develop understanding of the issues & engage all stakeholders: community, private sector client, government, IFC/MIGA teams
- Develop trust with the parties: no judgement on merits of complaint at this stage What it involves:
- Stakeholder mapping; conflict assessment
- Explain different CAO processes and ensure informed decision making
- Allow parties an opportunity to select process they want to initiate (Dispute Resolution or Compliance)
Dispute
Resolution
Dispute Resolution can be beneficial in:
- Empowering parties to determine outcomes
- Providing a voluntary process
- Exploring creative solutions
- Building relationships
- Achieving remedy
CAMEROON
Chad-Cameroon Pipeline Project
- Construction of 1070 km pipeline to transport crude oil from Chad to floating facility 11-km off the Cameroon coast with IFC support.
- CAO has convened parallel mediation processes since 2012 on complex set of issues including environmental and health impacts, HIV/AIDS, and loss of livelihood.
- By 2014, agreements on four individual complaints.
- By 2017, agreements with communities of fishermen, indigenous peoples, and farmers.
- CAO will continue monitoring implementation of these three community agreements over the coming months.
Compliance
- Focus is on IFC/MIGA performance
- Appraisal identifies which complaints merit investigation
- Serious environmental and social concerns?
- Systemic importance?
- Drawing on international expertise
- How IFC/MIGA has implemented its commitments
- Understand underlying causes to any gaps
UGANDA
Bujagali Hydropower Project
- Bujagali is run-of-the-river power plant on Nile River with 100-kilometer transmission line.
- $750 million public-private partnership by Bujagali Energy Limited.
- $130 million IFC loan, $115 million MIGA guarantee, and financing from World Bank, African Development Bank, and European Investment Bank.
- CAO received 8 complaints from communities and individuals over the past 16 years.
- Numerous alleged harms including: lack of worker compensation, wages, and benefits; inadequate land displacement compensation; crop loss; and inadequate biodiversity protection.
- IFC re-financing project and complainants hopeful that resettlement and worker-related compensation will be resolved.
Advisory Work
www.cao-grm.org
- Important resource for learning
- Improving performance of IFC/MIGA Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) 2121 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20433, USA Email: CAO@worldbankgroup.org Phone: +1 202 458 1973 Fax: +1 202 522 7400 www.cao-ombudsman.org https://twitter.com/CAOoffice https://www.facebook.com/CAOoffice
CONTACT US
Learn more about our work this year at CAO-AR17.org
WEligibility - Compliance
- The complaint pertains to a project that IFC/MIGA is participating in, or is actively considering.
- The issues raised in the complaint pertain to CAO’s mandate to address environmental and social impacts of IFC/MIGA projects.
- The complainant is, or may be, affected by the environmental and/or social impacts raised in the complaint.
Complaints deemed by CAO to be malicious, or generated to gain competitive advantage, are ineligible for assessment.